Friday, December 30, 2011

Democracy or Bust

Less legislation, more politics

R. C. Rajamani
Share  ·   Comment (1)   ·   print   ·   T+  
The winter session passed far fewer Bills than in the agenda; the Lokpal Bill was passed at the eleventh hour.
The winter session passed far fewer Bills than in the agenda; the Lokpal Bill was passed at the eleventh hour.
Parliament has become a place for political battles rather than a forum to discuss issues and make laws.
 

  1. Sunday in the Park With George: Sid Harth

    onlinecogitoergosum.com/
    2 days ago – The Wall Shit Journal and I: Sid Harth – blogs democracy. blogsdemocracy.soup.io/post/…/The-Wall-Shit-Journal-and-I-Sid. Jun 9, 2011 ...
    YouYou +1'd this

  2. Staff | The Tobin Project

    www.tobinproject.org/about/leadership-staff/staff
    He also has worked at a foreign policy think tank, where he conducted research on democratic transitions, and in investment banking. Sidharth earned a B.A., ...

  3. Devil-may-care: Sid Harth: Democracy Sucks: Sid Harth

    devilmaycaresidharth.blogspot.com/.../democracy-sucks-sid-harth_1...
    Aug 16, 2011 – G.P.SAMPATH KUMAR B.S. Yeddyurappa (centre) walking to the Raj Bhavan with ministerial colleagues and supporters on July 31 to submit his ...
    YouYou shared this

  4. Devil-may-care: Sid Harth: Democracy Sucks: Sid Harth - Yes

    devilmaycaresidharth.blogspot.com/.../democracy-sucks-sid-harth.ht...
    Aug 16, 2011 – Devil-may-care: Sid Harth Saturday, August 13, 2011 Publish, Oops, Promise or Perryish: Sid Harth Too Soon? Cuomo, Clinton Top 2016 Poll ...
    YouYou shared this

  5. News, Views and Reviews: Sid Harth

    realcogitoergosum.net/
    News, Views and Reviews: Sid Harth ... A democratic government is the only one in which those who vote for a tax can escape the obligation to pay it. Alexis de ...
    YouYou shared this on Blogger · Dec 26, 2011

  6. Democracy Sucks: Sid Harth » My Sister Eileen: Sid Harth

    mysistereileen.com/?p=1900
    Aug 16, 2011 – 23 hours ago – It's the Budget, Stupid: Sid Harth Tuesday, August 9, …. this country into a European-style social democracy while ...

  7. Democracy in action, Oops, inaction » My Sister Eileen: Sid Harth

    mysistereileen.com/?p=4394
    2 days ago – Aug 9, 2011 – Jun 27, 2011 – My Sister Eileen: Sid Harth » The Devil and a …. the government-approved Lokpal bill has been tabled in the Lok ...
     

  8. Democracy Sucks: Sid Harth « USA: News, Views and Reviews

    cogitoergosumusa.com/?p=1771
    Aug 16, 2011 – 23 hours ago – It's the Budget, Stupid: Sid Harth Tuesday, August 9, …. this country into a European-style social democracy while ...

  9. Democracy Sucks: Sid Harth « USA: News, Views and Reviews

    cogitoergosumusa.com/?p=1778
    Aug 17, 2011 – Is that a democratic protest? Giving the Hell to the innocent is what it was and still it is. Anna Hazare is using lot of modern gadgets, ...
     

  10. Columns - Sidharth Bhatia - DNA

    www.dnaindia.com › COLUMNS
    Sidharth Bhatia has been a journalist for over three decades in the print and ... The Greek word for the people is 'demos', whence the word democracy, rule by ...
 
 

Newspaper readers, TV viewers and even journalists over a generation have grown accustomed to witnessing Parliament as a place for political battles rather than a forum to discuss issues and make laws for national progress. Though the government-opposition confrontation is an inevitable feature in a democracy that the country is used to since independence, frequent adjournments amid chaotic scenes began in the mid-1980s. This has continued through to the new millennium.
A generation of reporters has come and gone without knowing what it is like to report Parliament and its function as a legislating and debating body. It is pretty much the case with MPs of the last two decades or so. Even ministers have come and gone without ever facing Parliament in any substantial manner. Nor have they had their performance properly scrutinised by the opposition or the public. Many a young reporter is known to have ‘covered' Parliament without filing any substantive copy on its legislative work.

BATTLEGROUND

In a scandal of sorts, the winter session of 2010 ended as a virtual washout due to the Opposition protest over the 2-G scandal.
The current winter session did not do any business in the first two weeks again on account of Opposition protest over several issues. The government paid a price to buy peace — it put on hold its decision to open FDI in multi-brand retail to the extent of 51 per cent. Though it was an executive decision and did not require the approval of Parliament, the politics surrounding economic reforms and coalition constraints have forced the government to go back on its decision, at least for the time being.
According to Jay Panda, a young parliamentarian of promise from Biju Janata Dal, the root of the problem is that the polity has become much more federal. For nearly 20 years, the country has been having coalition governments with a great deal of regional assertion, but parliamentary rules don't reflect that. The rules go back to pre-independence times. “Unless we sort out the rules, there will always be these clashes and noise,” says Panda.
Leader of the Opposition in the Rajya Sabha Arun Jaitley puts the issue in perspective: “As far as disturbances in Parliament go, my own preference is strongly in favour of a debate. Parliamentary obstructionism can be a part of parliamentary tactics but I admit it should be used in the rarest of rare cases. I think this tendency of too much obstructionism arises when there is a breakdown of consultation between government and opposition groups, or when a crucial debate isn't being allowed.”
The truth is that Jaitley's views could well have justifiably come from a Congress member at the time of the NDA government before 2004. Both the Congress and BJP, the two major political forces, have been guilty of turning Parliament into a battleground to win political points over each other.

DISAGREEMENT

While the financial cost of running Parliament is considerable, no less is the intellectual cost. Countless man hours go into the entire gamut of conducting a day's session. The staff of ministries and departments pore over members' questions to prepare the answers. Members themselves and their supporting staff spend enormous time to prepare questions, special mentions, notices of calling attention motions, private member's Bills and various other parliamentary devices to elicit vital information from the Government, on behalf of the people they represent. All this stupendous effort comes to a naught when the House stands adjourned without transacting any business. Members are often frustrated when their starred questions that are to be answered by ministers on the floor of the House go for a toss because of adjournment.
During the years, there have been informal ‘agreements' to let the Question Hour function whatever be the provocation for protest. A similar ‘agreement' envisaged that any member rushing to the ‘Well' of the House be suspended for the rest of the day. Yet another was ‘no work, no pay' norm. All these have remained only as ‘agreements' sans implementation.
Wasting Parliament time is a crime against democracy, a crime against the people, the teeming millions who, braving sun and rain, heat and cold stand in serpentine queues to vote to elect their representatives.

PASSING BILLS

The media has also failed to effectively mobilise public opinion to force the government and the opposition to ensure that Parliament functions in a normal manner. It seems to be happy with reporting ‘glamorous' stories of disorder. There is another side that goes unnoticed as the media tends to treat it as being unglamorous and really not newsworthy. We do have a number of serious-minded members who make thought-provoking and learned speeches on any given issue. There are experts from various fields too among members.
Speech by an authority on a subject matter, of any piece of important legislation, throws revealing light on the matter, leading to a better understanding of its significance and implications. In the past, we had members with such calibre. To cite a few, there were members like H V Kamath, Madhu Limaye, Minoo Masani, N G Ranga, Jyotirmoy Basu, P Ramamurthy, Bhupesh Gupta, Inderjit Gupta and others.
Today, since a lot of time is wasted each day, important Bills are rushed through at the eleventh hour without discussion. For the first time in India's Parliamentary history, the Finance Bill was passed without a word being spoken on it, in August 2004 during UPA-1. Passing Bills wholesale in the last few days of any session is a familiar feature today.
The just-concluded winter session passed far fewer Bills than were in the original agenda. And several Bills that have a bearing on reforms and faster economic growth continue to remain in cold storage.
The Lokpal Bill, seen as ‘The Bill' of the session, was scheduled for the last few days for discussion and passage.
Will the government and the Opposition come together during the few months before the budget session of 2012 to sort out matters so that Parliament returns to perform its primary function — to debate and legislate?
One hopes this doesn't remain a mere New Year wish.
(The writer is a New Delhi-based freelance journalist.)
(This article was published on December 29, 2011)
 
 
 



Congressman Mike Kelly
Wants To Create Opportunity For Small Businesses, Not Roadblocks.
Kelly.House.gov
Comments:
The hope that the political parties will sort out matters so that Parliament returns to perform its primary function ,alas,will remain as a wish only as none of the parties care for the values of parliamentary democracy. Parliament has become a platform for hurling accusations and counter accusations. Secency and decorum have been thrown out. Disruption is the norm now. Only enlightened media like the Hindu/Business line are showing concern. The electronic media is after sensation and thriving on disorder in the Parliament in an unethical manner. I think only a people's movement aided by papers likeThe Hindu/Business line can bring back Parliamentary democracy to normalcy from its present chaotic functioning. Budgets are guillotined and bills passed in a rush without debate. It is nothing but negation of Parliamentary Democracy.
from:  ramk
Posted on: Dec 30, 2011 at 08:15 IST
                                  
Thank you.
Your comment has been received and will be moderated.

Back to article


My dear R C Rajmani,

I am Sid Harth.

All that wisdom in 500 and or less words?

R C Rajmani, I am going to nominate you, before anybody else, including your mother-in-law for IgNobel Peace Prize.

Get a haircut, Oops, salary cut before appearing in white (only tie and nothing else) dinner. Fig leaf, optional. No cameras, video cameras, listening devices, recording whirling dervishes, bag lunches, copies of National Inquirer, Oops, (Philadelphia) Inquirer, local and national historian, National, Oops, International Poet Laureate, barking and/or silent dog, sleepy (Tom) cat, a mice, Oops, mikes or two. No turtle, please. They serve turtle soup.

What rewards: Failed Doomsday Predictions, Beer-Loving Beetles, Effects of a Full Bladder on Decision-Making, The “Theory of Structured Procrastination”, and the Wasabi Fire Alarm?

Why, the IgNobel prizes do! The prizes that make you laugh, and then make you think.

Do you, really, very much more, think that India has a democracy?

...and I am Sid Harth@sidileak.com
Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line.
Comments to: web.businessline@thehindu.co.in. Copyright © 2011, The Hindu Business Line.

...and I am Sid Harth@sidileaks.com
Posted by at

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)